Monday, August 4, 2008

Indie Engagment Rings

We've been talking a lot about engagement rings of late, from my vintage ring, to my silly plastic ring, and I wanted to do a roundup of some lovely indie rings. Rings are very personal, and from all the stories and comments I've read, it's clear that the intent of the giver and the wearer incredibly important, but this post is about the spirit of the rings themselves. I love my vintage ring for a million reasons, but I love knowing that it carries the story of another woman who wore it for a lifetime before me, and a jeweler who made it by hand. I also love modern rings that were made by hand, and nothing beats supporting independent artists. Keep leaving your ring stories in the comments. I love reading them, and I'm sure I'm not alone.
This simple knotted gold ring is reader Laura's engagement ring, since she didn't want a diamond. She says that everyone she shows it to seems to dislike it, but not me, I'm in love with it.



I also love tear shaped sapphire ring from Conroy + Wilcox which is also made with a diamond.
These rings by Sarah Perlis are lookers, but what I love the best about them is that they are made with rough cut diamonds, which is such a celebration of imperfection.
This ring is also by Sarah Perlis, and it has a classic look to it, while still being unique and simple.
And finally, my friend Lauren's engagement ring, made by conceptual artist Tobias Wong as part of his diamond project. The hidden diamond ring, because "who else should care."

Exactly. The perfect solution to the diamond Olympics.

31 comments:

Autumn Witt (future Autumn Witt Boyd) said...

I love my engagement ring but it was a journey. When we first started talking about getting married, my fiance's mother told him he could give me a diamond ring from his deceased grandmother, but he knew nothing about it. He told me, I presumed it was round, and got to looking at ways to set it. A few months later he found out it was a marquise, and when he told me, I literally almost cried.

Which is so silly! I just had all these settings in my head that would work for a round, and not a marquise, which I thought of as so 80s and ugly. He promised me it was a good size and sparkly, and he adored the grandmother who wore it, so I decided to try to love it and see what I could find to do with it (it was in a huge yellow gold and turquoise setting, which was perfect for her, an artist who lived in New Mexico, but not really me, so there was no question that we would reset it).

Thank goodness I went to a few high end jewelry stores and told them my dilemma-- a salesperson at one of them, after scoffing that "we don't carry marquises, no one wears them these days" showed me a beautiful yellow diamond marquise set sideways, and I fell in love.

I did a lot of hunting but couldn't find anything premade that would work. I wanted something with an antique vibe, so we found an awesome local jeweler who helped us design a ring with milgrain and some tiny diamonds in the setting, and made it from scratch. My ring is totally unique and exactly my style, yet embodies the history of the family I'm about to marry into. It's precious to me and I love it!

Anna said...

Oh, yay for this post! My ring is a green stone (tsavarite? A green sapphire? I don't know for sure and don't really care) set in white gold that my fiance had custom made (with my sister's help) and I love it. Neither one of us felt totally cool with diamonds, my job involves working with people from the parts of the world that get exploited for them. My fiance said that green just makes him think of me, and I was really touched by his efforts to get something that felt like me, not just a giant piece of bling. I do get bling envy every once in a while, but then I think about how unique my ring is and how if really fits my style, and I am instantly over it. Plus - i am really glad we aren't starting our lives together in debt for a piece of jewelry.
Check out Dawes Design for some other awesome rings - she makes a ring with a square peridot stone that is really, really gorgeous.

Faith said...

Ah! My ring is from Conroy Wilcox, and they are making our wedding rings too. I have a very plain and flat setting of a rosecut stone. I love it! It feels special and meaningful, since we chose it together, but also not ostentatious or 'bling.'

Nothing wrong with bling, but I wanted something flat - I do a lot of cooking and I didn't want to be picking biscuit dough out of the ring prongs for the duration of my marriage!

It's totally simply and different from the norm, which I can't help but love, too.

stephanie brown said...
This post has been removed by the author.
stephanie said...

my wedding band is extremely special to me. my great-grandma gave it to me when i was 17. i worked in the nursing home where she lived and i would often sit with her for hours while she told me wild tales of her life. she was a wonderful woman. she would sit and read to people that were dying and she always talked to EVERYONE and made them feel at home. i wore the ring all the time and eventually had it fitted to my ring finger because i knew it would be my wedding band. it was her 25th wedding anniversary ring from her 2nd husband.
soon after my now husband and i started dating, she broke her hip and her health started to go down hill. i often stayed late in the night with her and one night he came to play cards with me and keep me company. there is one time in the night that she woke up and smiled at him and nodded to me. she fell into a deep sleep and later passed early in the morning. i will never forget her and everytime i look at my beautiful ring i'm reminded of her.

*my husband did an excellent job of complimenting that ring with my engagement ring. don't want to leave him out. he picked it out by himself and i couldn't of been more surprised when he proposed with the big diamonds. i love my rings.

Blablover5 said...

My engagement ring is pretty standard in that it is a simple tiffany setting to work with our wedding band but really different as it's a sapphire and not a diamond.

I really don't care for diamonds at all, and love blue (as most people can figure out pretty quickly). I've never had anyone accuse me of it not being an engagement ring but even if they do well poop on them.

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y139/blablover5/Wedding/DSCN0473.jpg

Rebecca said...

For a long time, I was unsure I even wanted an engagement ring - I was uncomfortable with the idea of diamonds, with the non-feminist social origins of womens' engagement rings (in Sweden, for example, the men and women both wear rings), the environmental and social implications of diamonds and with the notion of beginning a life together with a lot of $ invested in a ring and not each other. Add to that the fact that many standard engagement rings seem almost mass produced, apart from the stone size, and I found it hard to get excited about an engagement ring. I decided to focus on designing a wedding ring instead.

But the sparkle. I fully admit to sparkle envy. And he's of a much more traditional vein than I am - the ring was important to him, though he agreed to respect my decisions. So I found a very modern-set sapphire ring on etsy that I fell in love with. It fit my aesthetic, ethical and budgetary requirements. And regardless, I just fell in love with the design.

It's hard though - he'll buy it in the next few months for the actual proposal, but already his friends are bothering him. Because I couldn't possibly want a ring that only costs $750. Because women always want something more expensive and blingy than they say. No one believes him that this is what I really want and that I have no other blingy ring agenda.

Grr. The ring comparison games have begun already, even with my opt-out ring.

Rachel said...
This post has been removed by the author.
Rachel said...

My fiance surprised me with a ring that he had chosen the stones for and had made especially for me. He knows that I love blue and the sea so he chose aquamarine for the centre and then smaller diamonds for the edging. He then was introduced to a jewellery maker in Hatton Gardens (area of London famous for it's jewellery especially diamonds) who made the ring for him.

It is beautiful and fits perfectly. So much so in fact that the guy he bought the stones from (an ethical diamond specialist) had it photographed for his website to advertise what he can do.

http://www.duttsonrocks.com/rock.php?here=0&a=53&d=2

invisiblyrose said...

i insanely love my ring, it was previously owned by my man's grandmother and before that was owned by the grandmother's great aunt. i love that it was handed down from not one but two happy and loving marriages, that it carries with it so much history and hope. and i love that while i will have it for the rest of my life, i am only a small part of its life, and my oldest grandchild will own it after me.

thank you for this post, i love your blog.

Ada said...

My engagement ring is very special to me. It consists of two small round diamonds-one was from my fiance's great grandmother's earring (his brother's wife to be has the diamond from the other earring) and the other diamond is from my father's family.
They happened to be the exact same size and shape, so we designed a setting that looked like it was looping the two together as a symbol of our joining families.

Anonymous said...

I, too, was anti-prong. Maine Jeweler Etienne Perret makes beautiful rings that are simple and psuedo-traditional, but unique. Mine is from him and I love it.

http://www.etienneperret.com/album/3

Blind, Irish Pirate said...

I actually am a woman who doesn't care about diamonds. Fiance knew that going into the engagement, thank God. Before he went ring shopping he talked to his parents, and without asking, they pulled out a ring that's been in their family for generations.

First, it was his grandfather's, who gave it to his wife. He died when fiance's dad was five, and once fiance's dad was old enough, he received his mother's engagement ring to propose to his girlfriend. And, so they passed it on, as per tradition.

So now I'm a third generation ring bearer. It's special, that way.

elisebeth said...

I happened to fall in love with a man who was divorced, which means that the beautiful ring that was his grandmother's ring was sort of out of the question for me, since it was worn by his previous wife. Darn!

But...he found me an antique ring that a jeweler friend had found at an estate sale. It's lovely. It's the original setting and original diamond from the early 1900's, art deco style, and couldn't be more beautiful. So, while I wish I could say that this ring has been passed down in his (or my) family, at least it's a ring that we both love, and will be passing on to our children.

Jessamyn Harris said...

lovely! my ring is a weird, super square white gold band with an emerald cut light blue sapphire that I got to pick out myself - it's my wedding ring, I had no engmt. ring though. anyway, I told the husband how much I wanted a forget-me-knot ring (like the one shown here, but with more ropy-ness) from http://www.curiosityshoppeonline.com/, but sadly I don't see them on their site now... maybe they just have them in the store? I still want one for some anniversary someday (it's just that usually we don't do presents). so cute!

Kini said...

Thank you for this post!

My ring is rather mainstream but it means the world to me. It is white gold with an ascher diamond and my fiance had it made based on elements we both liked from the many, many rings we had seen but never fallen in love with.

With so much hype that's anti-diamonds and pro-recycled, I sometimes feel guilty that my ring is new and has a diamond. But it was independently made. And it's just for me, there is not another one out there.

Even better, the first day I wore it to work a co-worker said "that ring is SO you!" It is undeniably the perfect ring for me.

charmedbride said...

ooh i love all of the rings you posted! i have more of a conventional ring that i love (small princess cut diamond on a simple, no frills band -- just the way i like it), but i kind of wish i would have considered a more indie route :)! are there indie wedding bands =P?

Cindy said...

I read something in here about men wearing engagement rings and had to share.

After I got my ring, my fiance expressed that he felt left out. He wanted a ring too. One day, I was walking around the mall and spotted a black, anodized steel ring at a jewelery cart and knew he would love it so I bought it, brought it home, and gave it to him. Without a word, he put it on and hasn't taken it off since.

There was no particular reason for giving it to him other than he simply wanted a ring. I mean, why deny the man something he wants? I get a ring, why can't he have one too?

Did anyone else do this?

J said...
This post has been removed by the author.
J said...

I have a traditional round shape diamond- but it's perfect for me because it looks larger than it is, but I know that it just looks larger because of the clarity of the cut and the height of the prong. It's also delicate without being too plain.

A friend of mine received a non-traditional ruby ring, and her fiance received a very simple band as his engagement ring. Now my fiance wants one, so we're going to start shopping for one! Why not? He wants something that says he's engaged, too!

Tara said...

I have to say all these stories about "indie" rings are wonderful!
And my ring isn't indie at all. That's right, it's from Tiffany. I originaly didn't care about the style of the ring, but I fell in love with the Tiffany Ribbon ring. My fiance and I are young and will be purchasing our first house soon and I really didn't think I would ever have my dream ring. But, he insisted because my favorite movie is "Breakfast at Tiffany's" and he knew how much I loved the ring.! It might be about the smallest ribbon ring Tiffany has ever made, but we didn't want to have to take out a loan for it. While it's not unique, it is different. And people always remark how it fits my personality (style and size wise). And, he's been wearing an "engagement" ring on his left hand for about a year now. We have yet to pick out his wedding band, but I'm so excited to pick out something with him that he will wear for the rest of his life!

Meg said...

I love these stories! For the record, my vintage ring is very traditional looking, and I love it. I decided I wanted a less indie looking ring for my engagement ring (though I love these....) and that I could get one like these later. Your engagement ring doesn't have to be your first and last lovely ring right? Hopefully you have a lot of happy years afterwards for various celebratory jewelry purchases... or so say I!

laura said...

I have a traditional engagement ring, art deco style, cushion cut.
super thin pave band with matching thin thin pave band.

But I'm going to the court house months before the "wedding"
I'm thinking of using this ring

http://style-for-style.blogspot.com/2008/07/no-price-but-priceless.html

laura said...

one more thing....
I see some comments citing ethical reasons for not wanting a diamond.
But there are blood rubies, and saphires too.
no matter what you choose, make sure it has a kimberely certificate.

there is also the question of "dirty gold"

a term that is totally new to me, I never knew that mining for gold had a huge negative effect on the environment.

now there is more to be conscious ofthan just picking a pretty ring.

p.s. I have that same knot ring, I love it.

MsTeacherLady said...

Love this post! Especially the hidden diamond and three stone above it, but I have to say I love the idea of a simple gold knot engagement ring. It's so beautifully simple and appropriate!

Elizabeth said...

I love the rough cut ones. Very nice.

Guilty Secret said...

Oh I just love that imperfect diamond! And the hidden diamond is so cool... very anti-Olympic (in a good way)

Tracy said...

we bought mine together in Thailand at a little jewelry store called Nova. It is simply silver and gold with a small, beautiful opal. It's simple, practical and best off all sturdy, I'm not very graceful so wanted something that could keep up with me.

lara miller said...

YAY! Thank you for posting this follow up and for mentioning my engagement ring! Want to know the coolest thing - not that it matters in the long run - but suddenly people are loving my ring! To me it's a perfect symbol of what we have - simple and easy love. Awwwwww. = )

heater said...

It is so rare to see other girls with non-traditional engagement rings. This post is so full of awesome!!!! I had wanted the ring I have on my finger for a long time. I was 17 (I'm 26 now) when I first saw it. I was passing time in my Grandpa's house, looking at pictures in architectural magazines. There was an ad for a company called Teno, and I looked it up as soon as I got home. I saw this ring and I knew I had to have it one day.

Fast forward to a year ago... my (then) boyfriend and I were wandering around in Soho while on vacation. Lo and behold we glance down a side street and there was the Teno store. I got to show him my ring in person, and try it on. Well in may he surprised me with it, and we're getting married in September!

It's 4.5m wide, steel band, with a round sapphire in the middle and two small diamonds on each side. I love it so so much. I get mixed reactions, but most of them are positive (not that it matters). :)

http://teno.com/yuriwanddi.html
It's much bluer than that in person.

Emmy said...

I'm so glad to read of other women with non-traditional rings :) Mine is actually a product of the "right hand ring" phenomenon. It's a pretty swirly intricate design. I love it so much, but I am sick of the comment "How are you going to put a wedding band with that?" It annoys me so much. The worst part is, however, that my fiancee's mom and sister don't believe we are actually engaged because I don't have a solitaire rock. Stupid traditions.